The editor’s guide
Choose a walking book by the way you will use it
The key difference is between a route guide and a map. Paddy Dillon’s Walking on Madeira describes 60 day walks across Madeira and Porto Santo. The Sunflower book combines 100 long and short walks with six car tours. The Rother title is another route collection, with 70 walks in the listed edition. These counts describe different selections; the highest number is not automatically the best choice for your trip.
Think about how you navigate. A book of route descriptions may be enough for choosing walks and understanding their character. The double-sided Tour & Trail Map, at 1:40,000, is a companion when you want a broader view of roads, paths and neighbouring routes. A map on its own does not replace current information about closures or conditions.
Older walking books can be valuable for landscape and history, but route access can change after publication. If you are choosing between editions, compare the date, included maps, GPS support and whether the title covers Porto Santo. Madeira’s official hiking page publishes live trail status and current access rules, including the reservation process for classified routes. Check it before each walk; no book can replace that live information.
Before you choose
- Are you planning long mountain routes, easier levada outings, or mixed driving and walking days?
- Does the edition include maps or downloadable route data that fit your navigation method?
- Verify route status locally; publication date is not a safety guarantee.
Reference: Official Madeira hiking status and access rules ↗
These comparisons use the titles’ stated scope and edition details. They are selection guidance, not claims that we have personally tested every book.